52 Ancestors: #33, Chester F. Kirk, Part 3: Veterinary Surgeon

Chester F. Kirk, date unknown

This is the third of "another story or four" about my paternal grandfather, Chester F. Kirk. This one is about Chester's third and fourth wives, an apparent extramarital liaison, and his third, fourth, and fifth children.

Leonard Irving Kirk birth, 1892

At the end of Part 2: Clockmaker, Chester was leaving behind his life as a clockmaker. The 1893 Bristol city directory noted only that he had "removed to Maine," presumably sometime since the 1891 directory had been published.¹ In fact, it had to have been before September 1892 that he took his children, Hazel and Kenneth, and his third wife, Hattie Schubert, north to his home state and settled in Auburn, Maine.

On 7 September 1892, Hattie gave birth to her only child with Chester, a son they named Leonard Irving Kirk. Chester's residence, and Leonard's place of birth, was Auburn. Just how long before that date they moved to Auburn is unknown, but I speculate that it was at least some months, and maybe as much as a year, earlier. For one thing, it seems unlikely they would have moved late in Hattie's pregnancy. For another, Chester had apparently been in Auburn long enough to set himself up in the new, and rather unlikely (for a former mechanic and clockmaker), occupation of veterinary surgeon.²

The next few years seem to have been, um, rather active ones for Chester – and not just in the context of his new profession.

Chester L. Kirk birth, 1893

On 17 December 1893, in Newcastle, Maine, one Nellie Crosman of Durham, Maine, gave birth to a son who was named Chester L. Kirk. His father: Chester Kirk, a "vetinary" surgeon, born in Warren and now supposedly a resident of Newcastle.³ There is no record of any marriage between Chester and Nellie, and no other records placing Chester in Newcastle (as near as I can tell, he was still living in Auburn); I imagine that since she had the baby in Newcastle (and I haven't yet figured out what she was doing there), she simply gave that as his residence.

What Happened to Nellie and Chester?
After this birth registration, both Nellie Crosman and Chester L. Kirk appear to have dropped off the face of the earth: No death records, no census records, no plausible Chester of any surname, born in Maine in 1893 with a mother named Nellie, have been found. However, after a great deal of sleuthing, I believe I have discovered what happened to Nellie and to my half great-uncle Chester... but that's another story.⁴

It was no doubt around this time that Chester's marriage to Hattie dissolved. While I have found no record of their divorce, I assume it must have occurred, because on 13 June 1894 he married Cora A. Grover of Waldoboro, Maine. He gave his residence as Auburn (although curiously, he did not appear in the 1893 Lewiston-Auburn city directory) and his occupation as veterinary surgeon – both of which were undoubtedly true – but other aspects of the marriage record stretched the truth quite a bit. For one thing, he claimed to be 35, when he was actually nearly 37 (probably to make his marriage to a 19-year-old slightly more palatable). Moreover, he claimed that this fourth marriage was actually his second, failing to state whether he was widowed or divorced (he was, of course, both).⁵

Marriage of Chester Kirk and Cora Grover, 1894

What Happened to Hattie and Leonard?
Unlike Nellie and Chester L., Hattie and Leonard were easy to trace. They returned to Bristol, Connecticut, where, around 1896, Hattie married Charles R. Goodenough, a brass manufacturer (whose family was once next door neighbors to the Schuberts) nearly as old as Chester. They had two children, Olive and Lester, before Charles's death in 1904. In 1910 she remarried, to Harry H. Cook. Hattie died in 1923 and is buried in Center Cemetery, Norfolk, Connecticut. Leonard was apparently adopted by his grandfather, Theodore Schubert, and took Schubert as his surname; he became an electrician. He married Rose V. _____ about 1927; they had one child, Richard. Leonard died in 1968.⁶

Once again, I have to wonder why a 19-year-old girl would marry a man twice her age, but once again it doesn't seem to have been a case of necessity. It was over ten months later, on 24 April 1895, that Cora had their first and only child, a son named Vinal. From the birth record it appears that Chester had relocated to Waldoboro, though other discrepancies make me wonder if he was actually around when Vinal was born: most notably, the father's name is recorded as "Charles A. Kirk" (which could be a transcription error – I haven't seen the original town register), and his birthplace as Lewiston.⁷

     

Vinal Kirk birth, 1895

     

Vinal Kirk death, 1896

Sadly, the baby survived less than year, dying of tuberculosis on 21 January 1896. On the death record Chester's name at least is correct, but his birthplace and occupation are blank, another indication that he may not have been present.⁸ In any event, Cora filed for a divorce, which was granted 24 December 1896, and Chester's fourth marriage came to an end after only two and a half years.⁹ This is the last sign of Chester until the 1900 census, when he surfaces in Andover, Maine.

What Happened to Cora?
Cora Grover remarried in April 1898, to a Thomaston sailor named William E. Dunbar. This evidently was a matter of necessity, as their daughter Gladys was born in August of that year. On 1 October of the following year, Cora died from puerperal septicemia.¹⁰

One more question that comes to mind is, where were Hazel and Kenneth throughout their father's shenanigans? Well, it's possible they were with Chester and Hattie, at least until their marriage broke up, but I think it more likely that Chester had parked them with his parents in Freeport, where they were enumerated in Silas and Sarah's household in 1900.¹¹ (Indeed, that may have been one reason Chester returned to Maine in the first place.)

1900 U.S. census, Freeport, Cumberland County, Maine, Silas Kirk household

To be continued in Chester F. Kirk, Part 4: Grandfather.

(Note: This post is in response to Amy Johnson Crow's "52 Ancestors in 52 Weeks" challenge at No Story Too Small.)

---

SOURCES

1. Bristol, Plainville and Terryville Directory 1893 (New Haven, Conn.: The Price & Lee Co., 1893), p. 66, entry for Chester Kirk, "rem[oved] to Maine"; database and digital images, "U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989," Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 3 Sep 2012).
2. “Maine, Birth Records, 1621-1922,” database and digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 5 Aug 2014), Leonard Irving Kirk, 1892. To the best of my knowledge, Chester had no significant training for his new profession, which he nonetheless practiced, apparently quite successfully, well into the 1930s.
3. “Maine Vital Records, 1892-1922,” database and digital images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org : accessed 9 May 2014), Chester L. Kirk birth, 1893.
4. And another post toward my 52 Ancestors total...
5. “Maine Vital Records, 1892-1922,” database and digital images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org : accessed 14 Dec 2012), Chester Kirk-Cora Grover marriage, 1894.
6. As with my "What Happened to Ellen?" sidebar in my previous post, I'm not going to try to cite sources for this paragraph. It's all available on Ancestry and/or FamilySearch. Interestingly, Leonard pursued the same profession as his half-brother Kenneth, who he may never even have known. In fact, both were working as electricians in Connecticut – Leonard in Bristol, Kenneth in Bridgeport – when they each registered for the draft in 1917.
7. “Maine Vital Records, 1892-1922,” database and digital images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org : accessed 9 Aug 2014), _____ [Vinal] Kirk birth, 24 Apr 1895.
8. “Maine Vital Records, 1892-1922,” database and digital images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org : accessed 9 Aug 2014), Vinal C. Kirk death, 1896.
9. "Maine Divorces, 1799-1903," database, Maine Genealogy (http://www.mainegenealogy.net : accessed 9 May 2014), entry for Cora Kirke & Chester A. Kirke, 24 Dec 1896, citing Maine Divorce Index, Maine State Archives.
10. See footnote number 6 (the first two sentences, that is).
11. 1900 U.S. Census, Cumberland County, Maine, Freeport, ED 42, sheet 12-A, dwelling 261, family 281, Silas Kirk household; digital images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org : accessed 9 Dec 2010).

52 Ancestors: #32, Chester F. Kirk, Part 2: Clockmaker

Chester F. Kirk, date unknown¹

This is the second of "another story or four" about my paternal grandfather, Chester F. Kirk. This one is about Chester's second and third wives, and his first two children.

At the end of Part 1: From Maine to Bristol, Chester had left the Hitchcock paper box shop for E. Ingraham's clock factory, and no longer lived with or near his in-laws, leading me to believe that he and Ellen had separated or divorced. And, I said, subsequent events  – which probably had their genesis right at the Hitchcock paper box shop – appear to bear this out.

Back in the 1880 census, four pages away from the Hitchcocks but also on Divinity Street, was the household of Jane Martin. Two of her daughters, Mary E. Martin and Hattie (Martin) Moore, worked in a "box shop," which was almost certainly Hitchcock's.²

1880 U.S. census, Bristol, Hatford County, Connecticut, Jane Martin household

 No doubt it was through one of those daughters that Chester met another Martin sister, Charlotte ("Lottie").³ Evidently they became quite well acquainted: on 2 Jul 1886, he married Lottie Martin,⁴ and six months later, on 9 Jan 1887, Hazel Mae Kirk was born.⁵

What Happened to Ellen?
Ellen, for her part, also remarried in 1886, to a Scottish minister, the Rev. Samuel Graham Neil. They had one child, a daughter Amna, born in 1888. I haven't discovered where they lived from 1886 to 1902, when they were in Bristol, apparently briefly, before removing permanently to Philadelphia. The Reverend Neil died of influenza and pneumonia in 1932 while on a visit to Scotland. His body was returned to the U.S., where he was buried in the West Cemetery in Bristol in Benajah Hitchcock's plot. I expect Ellen is probably buried there as well; she was still living in Philadelphia in 1940, and the cemetery inscriptions were compiled in 1934.⁶

Chester remained at Ingraham for the remainder of his residence in Bristol.⁷ The E. Ingraham Co. had been manufacturing clocks in Bristol since 1840, and was famous for intricately decorated cabinet clocks and "visible pendulum spring clocks" with eight-day striking movements, such as these examples from an 1897-98 Ingraham catalog.⁸

     

Typical Ingraham cabinet clock

     

Typical Ingraham visible pendulum spring clock

Pendulum clock built by Chester Kirk, ca 1890

I remember staying overnight at my grandmother's house and listening, late at night, to the striking of the pendulum clock that graced her dining room – a clock made by my grandfather during his time at Ingraham. Though much more rudimentary in design than a typical Ingraham clock and with little ornamentation, it's easy to see the "family resemblance."⁹

West Cemetery (Bristol, Conn.), Lottie A. Kirk gravestone

After Hazel, Chester and Lottie had one more child, on 24 November 1889: a son, Kenneth Allen Kirk.¹⁰ Chester's second marriage lasted no longer than his first, but for a very different reason: just a year after Kenneth's birth, Lottie died on 25 November 1890, at the age of 33.¹¹ She is buried in West Cemetery in Bristol (or Plainville).¹²

Perhaps it's not surprising that Chester, left suddenly with a one-year-old and a not-quite-four-year-old, remarried rather quickly. On their 2 Jul 1891 wedding day, his third wife was a couple of months shy of 18 – just about half Chester's age.¹³ Hattie Schubert was the daughter of Theodore Schubert, a German immigrant clockmaker employed at Ingraham.¹⁴ It's hard to say why this girl would marry a man twice her age, taking on two small children in the bargain. On the face of it, the marriage doesn't appear to be a matter of necessity; their only child would not be born for over a year. Possibly Hattie was pregnant, but miscarried after the marriage. One more thing I will never know.

What I do know is that before September 1892, Chester and Hattie pulled up roots and moved,¹⁵ with Hazel and Kenneth, to Auburn, Maine, where Chester began a new career as – of all things – a veterinarian.

Entry for Chester Kirk, 1893 Bristol city directory: "rem[oved] to Maine"

To be continued in Chester F. Kirk, Part 3: Veterinary Surgeon.

(Note: This post is in response to Amy Johnson Crow's "52 Ancestors in 52 Weeks" challenge at No Story Too Small.)

---

SOURCES

1. Photo of Chester F. Kirk, date unknown; Kirk-Murphy Family Collection, privately held by the author, Virginia Beach, Virginia. Chester's daughter Geneva Kirk probably gave this tiny photo to her nephew Marshall Kirk, from whom the author inherited it in 2005.
2. 1880 U.S. Census, Hartford County, Connecticut, Bristol, ED 25, p. 26, dwelling 225, family 290, Jane Martin household; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://search.ancestry.com : accessed 31 Aug 2012). Lottie is not enumerated in this household and I have been unable to find her elsewhere.
3. 1870 U.S. Census, Litchfield County, Connecticut, New Hartford, p. 72, dwelling 517, family 549, Harvey Martin household; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://search.ancestry.com : accessed 31 Aug 2012). Jane, all the children from the 1880 census, and Lottie, are in the 1870 household, thus tying Lottie to this family. It was most likely Hattie, who maintained contact with and visited Chester and her niece and nephew in Maine in later years, who introduced him to Lottie.
4. Greenleaf Cilley and Jonathan P. Cilley, The Mount Desert Widow: Genealogy of the Maine Gamble Family (Rockland, Maine: Knox County Historical and Genealogical Magazine, 1895), p. 170; digital images, Internet Archive (http://archive.org/details/mountdesertwidow00cill : accessed 5 Mar 2012).
5. Ibid. Also, Certificate of Death for Hazel Mae Clark, 11-10-1962, State of Maine Department of Health and Welfare, undated photocopy of typed certificate stamped "NOT FOR LEGAL PURPOSES", Kirk-Murphy Family Collection, privately held by the author, Virginia Beach, Virginia. 
6. I'm not going to try to list all the sources for this paragraph. Suffice it to say that I did turn up documentation on Ancestry.com 18-20 Jul 2014, which I will be happy to relate to anyone who might be interested. I'm pretty sure, by the way, that "Amna" really is the daughter's name; at first I thought it was a typo for "Anna" but then found other instances that definitely have an "m" in them.
7. Bristol, Plainville and Terryville Directory for [year] (New Haven, Conn.: Price, Lee & Co., 1888-1891), entries for Chester Kirk (1888; 1890-91; 1891); database and digital images, "U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989," Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 3 Sep 2012).
8. Clocks Manufactured by the E. Ingraham Company, Catalogue 29, 1897-98 (Bristol, Conn.: E. Ingraham Co., 1897), p. 52, Bazar, p. 62, Lily; digital images, Internet Archive (https://archive.org/details/clocksmanufacturedingrahamcompany29bris : downloaded 9 May 2014).
9. Chester Kirk pendulum clock, ca 1890, privately held by the author, Virginia Beach, Virginia; photographed by the author, 2004. The clock passed from Chester's last wife, Mary (Hodsdon) Kirk, to their daughter Geneva Kirk, who passed it on to the author sometime in the 1980s. It is not an "official" Ingraham clock; that is, it does not bear the Ingraham name. I speculate that employees may have been free to use the facilities to build their own clocks during their off hours. Though this clock now graces my living room, it – alas – no longer runs or strikes; the mechanism is simply worn out. 
10. Cilley and Cilley, p. 170. Also, "United States, World War One Draft Registration Cards, 1917-1918," index and images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org : accessed 26 Apr 2012), Fairfield County, Connecticut, 5 Jun 1917, No. 786, for Kenneth Allen Kirk.
11. Bristol, Plainville and Terryville Directory 1891 (New Haven, Conn.: Price, Lee & Co., 1891), p. 6, List of Deaths in Bristol, entry for "Kirk Lottie A., Nov. 25, '90 [age] 33".
12. Find A Grave, database and images (http://www.findagrave.com : accessed 27 Sep 2012), memorial #46891025 for Lottie A Kirk, with photo of marker, citing West Cemetery (Plainville, Hartford County, Connecticut), plot 14, memorial and digital photo by C Greer (19 Jan 2010). The last two digits of year are illegible in the photo; the memorial gives the date of death as Nov. 29 [sic], 1889.
13. Bristol, Connecticut, Registrar of Births, Marriages, and Deaths, marriage license with clergyman's certification, #292, Chester F. Kirk and Hattie B. Shubert, 1891; certified (embossed) photocopy issued 14 May 1993.
14. Bristol, Plainville and Terryville Directory 1891, p. 66, entry for Theodore Schubert. 
15. Bristol, Plainville and Terryville Directory 1893 (New Haven, Conn.: The Price & Lee Co., 1893), p. 66, entry for Chester Kirk, "rem[oved] to Maine"; database and digital images, "U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989," Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 3 Sep 2012). The September 1892 date and the destination of Auburn will be documented in the next installment.